Matthew Bizzarro

Matthew Bizzarro

LIC RE Principal Broker/Owner

As a graduate of the prestigious Charles F. Dolan School of Business at Fairfield University, Matthew Bizzarro takes great pride in his boutique firm, The Bizzarro Agency. Matthew founded The Bizzarro Agency on his extensive experience and knowledge of real estate and business ethics. He has transformed the market with his cutting edge and honest approach. He has been serving Uptown Manhattan and The Bronx real estate markets for over a decade and a half. Matthew is widely regarded as one of the most knowledgeable and well-connected brokers in the area. His thriving business is founded upon honesty, professionalism and market expertise. Matthew’s rank as a top sales agent is a testament to his dedication and results-driven professional approach.


March 2018 by nickvivian , Highly likely to recommend
Matthew was extremely knowledgeable and helpful throughout the long buying process. He was easy to reach by phone and email and always willing to answer questions as this was my first home purchase. I highly recommend him and his team for anyone buying in Upper Manhattan!!

January 2018 by rebeccarosesteingut , Highly likely to recommend
Helped me rent a Multi Family home in Washington Heights, New York, NY.

We were hoping to avoid paying a fee, but quickly found out how thoroughly Matthew would earn his fee. We are so glad we paid the fee because we found an apartment that was better than we could have dreamed, under budget. He''s the best!

January 2018 by user78829021 , Highly likely to recommend
Bought a home in 2017 in Washington Heights, Manhattan, New York, NY 10040.

Our experience with buying a coop with Matt could not have been any more pleasant. Matt was extremely helpful by often communicating with us on the status of the process at every step. He often went beyond his responsibilities and coached us through the entire coop approval and buying process in great detail. Matt is a great resource, understands this particular market very well since he lives in it and always treated us as if we were his own neighbors. We were very lucky to have Matt's advise and would highly recommend him.

January 2018 by Alice Kim , Highly likely to recommend
Bought a Cooperative home in 2017 in Washington Heights, New York, NY.


Matthew is nothing short of spectacular! As a first time buyer, I was unfamiliar with the whole buying process (especially in NYC). He was personable, knowledgeable, patient, and most of all comforting. The process was incredibly stressful but with his guidance, I made it through. He even answered my messages at 11 pm!

I definitely recommend him and his team to anyone in search of a new home. Will definitely be using his services again if I ever need to move (but fat chance of that because my new apartment is a dream). THANKS SO MUCH AGAIN MATTHEW!

January 2018 by Allison Worrell , Highly likely to recommend
Bought a Condo home in 2016 in Melrose, Bronx, NY.

3 Thumbs Up! A hallmark of a good real estate agency is how they handle a situation when things don’t go according to plan. For reasons outside of our control (bidding wars, legal hurdles, low inventory, etc.) it took more than 6 months for me to buy an apartment. But the Bizzarro Agency held my hand through the process, and always made my house hunt a priority. As a first time homebuyer I’m grateful to have worked with Matthew and the Bizzarro Agency. They’re responsive, professional, and unpretentious… I’ve already started recommending them to friends and family.

January 2018 by Jay Harris , Highly likely to recommend
Bought a Cooperative home in 2017 in Washington Heights, New York, NY.

My fiancé and I cannot say enough positive things about Matthew Bizzarro & The Bizzarro Agency. We found Matthew online stumbling upon a few great listings he had on Zillow.com. After a quick phone call to discuss our ‘wish list’, Matthew was able to show us a few listings that fell within our price range, and the final apartment we viewed turned out to be the perfect fit.

What put Matthew and his team apart from other agencies was his knowledge of the area, honesty, professionalism and responsiveness. After picking our apartment, there were many factors outside of our control (legal hurdles, scheduling difficulties, etc.) which resulted in us waiting 8 months to purchase our apartment. Throughout it all, Matthew went above and beyond to communicate with all parties involved (the seller, our bank, our attorneys, etc.) to ensure we closed. As first-time homeowners who were unfamiliar with the NYC market, Matthew was more than a realtor: he served as a negotiator, adviser, and was available to answer our questions at a moment’s notice.

With such a big purchase and a potentially stressful process for many, we HIGHLY recommend The Bizzarro Agency to anyone who is looking for professionals to represent them in their home buying search. Thank you Matthew!!!

January 2018 by gregmaro , Highly likely to recommend
Bought a Cooperative home in 2017 in Washington Heights, New York, NY.

Buying a home—especially for the first time as we did—exposes every raw nerve. Be ready for your relationships to be tested and finances scrutinized. It''s an uncomfortable and deeply emotional experience; David and I learned that if something could go wrong, it probably will.

Enter Matthew Bizzarro: professional in demeanor, kind, generous with his time and toggles effortlessly between professor, therapist and advocate. He and, by extension, his firm go above and beyond to steward in a new generation of homeowner.

We trust Matthew because he consistently displayed a high level of expertise, competency and good judgement throughout the entire home buying process. My husband and I actively recommend The Bizzarro Agency without any hesitation to our family, friends, and colleagues.

January 2018 by JordanClarke32 , Highly likely to recommend
We connected, but it did not work out. Looking in Harlem, GA

Mr. Bizzarro was very professional and worked with my family for us to get the best real estate service we could. Unfortunately it did not work out with the Bizzarro agency in the end, but Mr. Bizzarro himself was a pleasure to work with during the brief time we did.

January 2018 by user0607175 , Highly likely to recommend
Bought a Condo home in 2017 in Melrose, Bronx, NY.

As a first time home buyer in the incredibly complex and competitive market of New York City, I was blessed to have the Bizzarro Agency on my side.

My fiancé and I managed to close on a property that fulfilled all of our needs (and more) while staying within our budget. We could not have closed without the knowledge and persistence of the Bizzarro team and our stellar realtor, Yodalis Moran!

Negotiations, cash buyers, and legal proceedings threw hurdles onto the six month process of closing, but Yodalis and the Bizarro agency stuck with us for the entire process and held our hand to the end.

They were professional, courteous, patient, persistent, and fierce when necessary. We love our new home in the South Bronx and could not have achieved this goal of our without Yodalis and the Bizzarro agency.

January 2018 by user7181233 , Highly likely to recommend
Bought a Cooperative home in 2017 in Washington Heights, New York, NY.

My experience with Matt was seamless, natural and easy-going. He was referred to me by my sister who purchased in the same neighborhood 2 years earlier - and I met during her purchase. I really thought I could do it on my own, but that clearly wasn''t working. I connected with Matt while I was at an open house. Afterward, we connected and we went through what my real needs were - with buying my first home. He made the entire process easier - breaking it down into steps. Matt is a wealth of knowledge in all of the neighborhoods - very impressive! Once my offer was in, he helped with the offer process and gave me very good advice. Matt made the coop application process manageable - and did so much of the work to put the package together to turn into the bldg management agent. That made my life a lot easier.

I can''t say enough good things about Matt and his team. I highly recommend Matt and the Bizzaro Agency, best decision you''ll make!

January 2018 by a347wy , Highly likely to recommend
Bought a Cooperative home in 2010 in Washington Heights, New York, NY.

Matthew made my first co-op purchase a breeze. He was friendly, knowledgeable and helpful in getting all my paperwork and co-op interview together. He was living next to the place I ended up buying so I trusted him. You know it''s a good neighborhood if he and his family are living in the same area. I would work with him again.

January 2018 by aislinn w , Highly likely to recommend
Sold a Cooperative home in 2017 in Washington Heights, New York, NY.

We recently had the pleasure of selling our apartment through the Bizzarro Agency. We''ve know Matt for years as a committed member of our community and neighbor. As our broker, he was positive, professional and committed to helping us throughout the process. I highly recommend him!

More of Matthew's Testimonials