About Matthew Bizzarro

Matthew Bizzarro is a devoted husband, father to four young children, and a passionate advocate for the Upper Manhattan community. He is the founder of BIZZARRO, a real estate brokerage that specializes in guiding and serving home buyers and sellers through the complicated New York City market.

Matthew Bizzarro planted his flag in Upper Manhattan in 2001 when working as a teacher at Mother Cabrini High School in Washington Heights. He spearheaded several community service programs, including eight mission trips to Louisiana and Texas to help victims of Hurricane Katrina. In addition, Matthew oversaw reading and after-school programs and engaged students in volunteer work at local food pantries, soup kitchens, hospitals, rehabilitation centers, and nursing homes.

Matthew turned to real estate as a way to generate additional income during the summer. He started by working with rental clients, and the experience left him feeling hollow. It wasn't until Matthew worked with his first home buyer that real estate felt gratifying. As a buyer's agent, he was able to make real connections with his clients. He learned about their children, their pets, and their dreams and became wholeheartedly invested in their goals.

When the local brokerage Matthew worked for merged with a large corporate firm, he decided to start his own. He founded BIZZARRO, formerly known as The Bizzarro Agency, in 2013, and he's never looked back.

Matthew has lived in Upper Manhattan for 20 years, and he's quick to rave about its incredible quality of life. Through BIZZARRO, Matthew has melded his passion for his community with his enthusiasm for helping aspiring homeowners achieve their dreams. When Matthew speaks about Upper Manhattan, he speaks from the heart, and he puts his money where his mouth is.

Every year for almost a decade, Matthew has sponsored the Washington Heights Chamber Orchestra and the Uptown Soccer Academy. He also contributes to Good Shepherd Women's Shelter and other charitable organizations in Upper Manhattan and the Bronx.

About The Agency

At Bizzarro, we're champions of Upper Manhattan and the Bronx. We don't just work here - we live here, too. So when our agents talk with clients about neighborhoods like Washington Heights, Inwood, West Harlem, or Riverdale, they're talking about home. As a result, we bring a level of knowledge and insight that would be impossible for any real estate agent based elsewhere.

We're also advocates for those who aspire to own a home. Homeownership is a big part of the American Dream, and we consider it a privilege to help our clients plant their flag on their little piece of NYC.

We understand how bewildering it can be to embark on buying a home for the first time. No one likes feeling left in the dark, and we insist on holding up a light for our clients.

  • We take the time to educate our clients on the home buying process. To us, no question is silly, and we take all the time necessary to help our clients grasp what's happening. We teach the things you won't learn on YouTube.
  • We're experts on our own neighborhoods, so we're able to give our clients the low-down on every building in the area. Is it right for you? There's no one better to help you decide.
  • We believe in protecting our clients during the home buying process, including guarding them against predatory third parties like unscrupulous lenders and attorneys. We have a network of service providers who share our values, and we trust them absolutely.
  • We know that to make an offer on a property and be taken seriously, buyers need to "have all their ducks in a row." We're the best duck wranglers you'll ever know.
  • We enjoy acting as real estate "Sherpas," guiding our clients through the least pleasant aspects of buying real estate, like dealing with co-op boards.
  • We're unfailingly honest with our clients about their options. When a client encounters barriers to homeownership, we try to find other ways to make it happen.
  • Once you work with us, you want to work with us. We think it's telling that so many of our former clients joined the brokerage, either as agents or in support roles.

Matthew Bizzarro founded Bizzarro in 2013, recognizing that real estate brokerages underserved his stomping grounds in Upper Manhattan. Few brokerages even had offices in the area, and it seemed that most of Manhattan’s realtors were only interested in placing clients in sleek lofts and new construction below 110th Street.

Matthew knew first-hand that Upper Manhattan offered an excellent quality of life, as well as price points that made a home in Manhattan affordable for many first-time buyers. As someone with a genuine passion for his community, becoming a trusted advisor in Upper Manhattan real estate evolved naturally for Matthew. He’s been a resident of Upper Manhattan for 20 years. And for almost a decade, he’s sponsored the Washington Heights Chamber Orchestra, as well as the Uptown Soccer Academy. He also contributes to Good Shepherd Women’s Shelter, local food donation projects, and other uptown charitable organizations.

Latest News

Are NYC Real Estate Bargains Gone?

Are NYC Real Estate Bargains Gone?

Home prices plummeted during the height of the pandemic, but they’re on their way back up and in some cases even higher than before the shutdown! Our founder and CEO, Matthew


NYC Real Estate Market (Including Rentals) Has Been Roaring Back to Life

NYC Real Estate Market (Including Rentals) Has Been Roaring Back to Life

New York City’s real estate market is roaring back, resulting in bidding wars for homes and rentals in certain areas. But as our founder and CEO, @Matthew Bizzarro, told @Che


The Bronx’s Lingering ‘COVID Discount’ on Real Estate Is Causing a Homebuyer Shift

The Bronx’s Lingering ‘COVID Discount’ on Real Estate Is Causing a Homebuyer Shift

NEW YORK (CBSNewYork) — Some real estate agents say they’re seeing a shift in recent months with New Yorkers moving from Manhattan to the Bronx.

The O’Shaughnessy family is sti